sunnuntai 29. maaliskuuta 2015

Some observations more about ancient European admixtures

I am not ready to make any large-scale comparisons yet, because so many things must be checked and ensured before it, but just for an excerise two qpAdm analyses.

1.  Yamnaya samples seem to be an admixture of Samara-HG and Iranians with smaller additions of Karelian and Scandinavian hunter-gatherer admixtures.  I got several possible results showing chisq below 1 (0.5-0.7).   Main proportions were EHG (Eastern hunter-gatherers) and Iranian, although some Armenian was also possible.  Indeed,  this may follow the idea of ancient Iranian linguistic connection with some East European people.

2.  I also checked Ashkenazi samples more precisely and found them being genetically very close Sicilians, but I was still able to find out a better composition by combining Early European Neolithic Farmers, Lebanese and Turkish samples. Chisq was typically around 1 or less.   It also was observable that although Ashkenazim and many Southeastern Europeans showed clear Turkish like admixture it likely is not from present-day Turks (with exception of some Greeks and many Cypriots) because no Asian admixture was detctable and as far as I know Turks have some Asian admixture.  So this was a bit puzzling.   No Asian, but minor North African admixture existed in some Mediterranean results.

keskiviikko 25. maaliskuuta 2015

Near Eastern admixture in South Europe

Haak et al. 2015 has led to confusion about the genetic shape of Southern Europeans.  Two examples  about those challenging points:

Sardinians 89.8% EN+3.2% WHG+7.1% Yamnaya
Ashkenazi 90.7% EN+0% WHG+9.3% Yamnaya

and later

Ashkenazi_Jew 3.7% EHG+95.5% EN+0.8% Nganassan+0% WHG 

EN stands for Early Neolithic Europeans, samples are very likely from Neolithic Hungary. 

Results show only a small difference in resnorm values between results.  Are Ashkenazim more original Southern Europeans than European themselves?  How we could explain this shift between original Europeans and original Near Easterners?   IMO,  it is quite hard to believe this kind of preserving isolation, even  among Ashkenazim.  This is definitely confusing because Jews came to Europe around 2000 years ago from Near East and analyses I have made using present-day samples show non-European admixture for Ashkenazim.  Very likely they have become more mixed lately in Europe and turning out to be like Neolithic Europeans, huh unbelievable.     (I have nothing against Ashkenazim people, my son-in-law is according 23andme's  test 98% Ashkenazi).

Another thing creating confusion is using Bedouins as a proxy for something.  Maybe it is not clear that Bedouins don't represent all Middle-Eastern migrations to Europe and are only an arrangement and substitute something that explains something in history, but real migrations has modified our genes many times more.  It is okay if  three or four ancient migrations can explain things, but it doesn't explain later migrations, possible from North Africa, Near East, Turkey ...  So Near Eastern Bedouin-like admixture can be Turkish as well, if we want to find out the history. 

My last observation belongs to Nganassans.   Almost all Europeans show in this study admixture with Nganassans.  They are a small isolated group in northernmost Siberia.   Although it is clear that also they are thought to be proxies, it is also quite suprising to see 2.8% Nganassan admix among French people, with almost lowest resnorm.  Does the resnorm mean in this case an error rate of 5% or more?  My conclusion is that Nganassans have Northeast European admixture, which is not observable using admixture analyses because they are a rather homogeneous group.         


 

tiistai 24. maaliskuuta 2015

Estimating ancient genes among present-day European populations, part 3

After adding the Karelian HG things "clicked" in Northeast Europe.  This Ancient Karelian sample is closely related to Yamnaya people, but with less or no European farmer ancestry.  This lack of farmer genes became in new results balanced by additional Hungarian Neolithic farmer genes, especially among northeastern and ancient Corded Ware samples, and as a result chisq  is now pretty much lower in Northeast Europe.   You see on the Excel-sheet also the older chisq for comparison.  It is worth of noticing that both northern hunter-gatherer groups (Scandinavian and Karelian) are necessary to obtain best fits in the north and that my second test proved the western hunter-gatherer (Hungarian neolithic HG) being quite distant for all present-day northern populations, even for some southern ones, like for Basques.

I tried also to find out the lacking piece that could complete certain South European admixtures.  The best fit was obtained among Greeks by adding something like Turkish-Iranian and in a case of Maltese and Sicilians also North African genes (Turkish-Iranian + Tunisian).  It is hard to say exactly for what this Turkish-Iranian stands for, anyway Lebanese, the best Near-Eastern admixture gave a poorer result.

Download new results here.

sunnuntai 22. maaliskuuta 2015

Estimating ancient genes among present-day European populations, part 2

Following my obvious quideline I substituted the Scandinavian hunter-gatherer group by Hungarian Neolithic hunter-gatherer (KO1).  My goal was to find out possible difference in relations between Yamnaya and both hunter-gatherer groups.   I thought that he result could reveal ancient migrations.   Indeed, the result shows possible genetic connection between Yamnaya, Corded Ware and Scandinavian cultures, which is of course reasonable from the historical perspective. The Hungarian hunter-gatherer looks more like belonging to some more southern diverged populations. 

I appreciate if someone with good mathematic skills could make a correlation analysis between all four groups and paying attention to differences between Excel-sheets, I myself am happy to see how tightly Yamnaya, Corded Ware and Scandinavian HG groups correlate.  It looks definitely like substituting Scandinavian HG's by the Hungarian one moves all Scandinavian similarity to the Corded Ware culture.  Drawing speculative conclusions I would say that also early animal husbandry connects these regions.  One of the most interesting questions is now related to new finds of ancient  yDna from the East European plain. 


Corded-Ware-LN
- Yamnaya 0.68
- Hun. farmer 0.175
- SC-HG    0.138

Corded-Ware-LN
- Yamnaya 0.804
- Hun. farmer 0.125
- Hun. HG 0.067

This same continuity between Yamnaya, Corded Ware and North Europe is observable widely among all North Europeans.

Download my earlier xls-sheet here
Download my new xls-sheet here

Next I try to estimate Eastern Hunter-Gatherers.  Possible eastern sinilarity with present-day populations would be interesting.

edit 22.03.15   Adding Karelian Hunter-Gatherer as a fifth admixture proportion decreased chisq (below 1 at best) in Northeast Europe, meaning a better fit. Concurrently the proportion of Hungarian Neolithic farmers in same results increased, as compensation to increased hunter-gatherer proportion.  This all was reasonable and expected.  But in the south the transition was minimal, for example Basques had no ancient Karelian admix and actually nothing changed.   This all looks so expected.  Incredible!     The biggest issue I have now, after the next update, is to find the lost South European admixture.


perjantai 20. maaliskuuta 2015

Estimating ancient genes among present-day European populations

Reich Lab's new Admixtools version 3 includes a new admixture calculator based on f4-statistics.  So here is my first effort to find out our Neolithic genetic admixtures.   This test is based on three European Neolithic sample groups:  Yamnaya culture samples,  Neolithic farmer samples from Hungary and Neolithic hunter-gatherer samples from Southern Scandinavia.  East-Asian samples were used additionally to find out possible Northeastern migrations.

So I had four admixture groups.  It wasn't enough, it became soon obvious that South Europeans had a fifth admixture dimension.  I tried to solve the problem and fit Near-Eastern samples to the model, because my previous test with Mixmapper showed a later Near-Eastern admixture in South Europe.  But at this time it didn't succeed.  Sure there is a solution and I'll try to find it later.  Just now some South European results show poor accuracy due to this unknown admixture proportion.  Best fit was obtained in Ukrainian, Belarussian, Cornwall and Basque results.   Results show elevated amounts of East Asian, which was the case also in Haak et al.  The reason is either in low-quality ancient samples or in the method itself. 

This new tool is exciting because it makes estimates fast and seems to have less problems caused by genetic drift, which are typical for admixture analyses.  But I have work to do to learn pros and cons. 

Download Excel-file here.


edit 20.03.15   Sardinian and Sicilian row names corrected.

edit 21.03.15  I did preliminary tests using HungaryGamba_HG, aka KO1, instead of Scandinavian hunter-gatherers.  KO1 was a hunter-gatherer found from Hungarian plain and lived around 5000 years ago and the genome is around as old as the Swedish hunter-gatherer Ajv58 used in my earlier test with other Scandinavian samples from the same period.

The result implies that KO1 shares less common ancestry with Yamnaya, Scandinavian obviously much more than KO1.  Replacing Scandinavian HGs by KO1 led to much higher Yamnaya and lower hunter-gatherer admixtures everywhere where the sum admixture of Yamnaya and Scandinavian HG was highest.   I am working with this but have not just now time to complete my tests.  

edit 21.03.15  Sorry about erroneous test, now corrected (underlined).  To be in a hurry is not a good thing.


keskiviikko 18. maaliskuuta 2015

Finestructure testing continues

This is my last test with Finestructure, now using East-Finns, Karelians and a lot of other North Europeans released recently by Estonian Biocentre.   After this moment I see no reason to continue with Finestructure, because Finestructure fails to work properly with (sub)populations showing high genetic drift, just like I noticed in my first experience.  It starts to accumulate internal drift to other bound populations, making a causality error.   One interesting notice however:  Russians in Kostroma seem to belong to the same old Finnic ancestry than Mordvas, not to the same one with Maris, as supposed in some studies.   This probably means that Meryan people belonged to a western branch of Finno-Ugric speaking people.

Doewload results here

lauantai 14. maaliskuuta 2015

Yamnaya likelihood among present-day populations in comparison to Early Neolithic farmers, Western huntergatherer and Iron Age Britons

This test tries to estimate how much present-day populations have preserved Yamnaya affinity.  Each of three ancient comparison groups are compared to Yamnaya samples and to present-day populations.  Populations scoring more are more Yamnaya-like than less scoring ones.  Positive scores mean that the population in first column has more Yamnaya admix than the ancient comparison group and vice versa with negative scores.  Please note that this test doesn't try to compare present-day populations to each other but to their position between ancient populations and ancient migrations.


Hungarian EN samples versus Yamnaya
 




Loschbour vs Yamnaya
























































Iron Age Britons versus Yamnaya




Some ancestral changes in Iron Age Estonia

QpAdm was designed to detect admixtures giving also probability and standard error statistics.  Two kind of parameters are inputted: admixtu...