tiistai 5. tammikuuta 2016

Neolithic Anatolian or Middle Eastern

I am still busy with my new test environment and to make it ready would take at least two weeks.  To keep my blog alive I made a small comparison between Anatolian Neolithic and BedouinB samples.   The history of  Middle Eastern migrations to Europe is still mostly unmapped and to resolve it would need a lot more scanned ancient data, for example from the Roman Iron Age.   But something can be done just now.  My comparison is based on two dstat-analyses

dstat(<Europop>,Mbuti:Anatolian Neolithic,Chimp)

and

dstat(<Europop>,Mbuti:BedouinB,Chimp).

Anatolian Neolithic is on the Y-axis and BedouinB is on the x-axis.   The plot tells that Armenians, Ashkenazim, Georgians, East Sicilians, Sicilians, Cypriots and South Italians deviate from the common European line towards Bedouins.  Spaniards, Basques and Sardinians deviate to the opposite direction.  What is remarkable is that Ashkenazim seem to own less Neolithic Anatolian and Bedouin admixtures than many South Europeans.*   Maybe they have more complex European admixture than South Europeans?

The Finns are split into two groups on the grounds of Corded Ware ancestry.   My older bifurcation was based on non-European admixtures and it was arbitrary in respect of the known history. 

* My fault, only Armenians and Georgians have more BedouinB than Ashkenazim,  Cypriots have it equally.



perjantai 4. joulukuuta 2015

North and South European ancient roots estimated using Dstat

Before moving ahead with new ideas I decided to make one more qpDstat comparisons using recently released ancient sample set and Estonian Biocentre's data. 

Qualifying the data using larger 1000genome data shows certain statistic error in EBC data and I am not happy to see that the EBC data with less SNPs distorts at least Finnish samples. 

Now I split 100 Finnish samples (downloaded from the 1000genome project) into two groups using qpDstat instead of using PCA, which seems to lead to a bias towards homogeneous and/or recently formed  populations.   The first Finnish group includes most similar samples with Corded Ware samples found from Germany, exluding 5 individuals showing more Swedish admixture than me. Usually I get in Gedmatch tests 5% less recent western admixture than average Southwestern Finns. Many approved samples show however more Corded Ware than me.  Another Finnish group includes samples showing least Corded Ware similarity.  It is of course possible to make different intrapopulational selections, but using Corded Ware samples made sense in a larger scale.

All sample sets are compared to British Kent poople.   I selected them because I thought them being a good fixed point and well-known for American readers.  I think that Irish or Orcadian samples could have been better though, just because they live on the opposite European fringe to the Bronze Age migrations. 










perjantai 27. marraskuuta 2015

Indigenous European Hunter-gatherer origin of Finns

I have been busy for a while with this blog, but after this writing I am going to start a new project and stay away from here for two weeks in preparing new data.

It has been some discussion about the origin of Finnish people.   Did they come from north, east, south or west?   But absolutely not from above or below.  An estimate given by Haak et al. 2015 gives us the origin of Finns: 25% early Neolithic farmers (compared to Norwegians with 48% early Neolithic farmers), 10% Siberians (compared to Norwegian 4%), 8% western hunter-gatherers (Norwegian 0%) and  50% Yamnaya (Norwegian 48%).  Because the Yamnaya settlement was already mixed holding eastern, western and southern roots we can assume that this kind of mixture existing in Finland is not necessarily just from a Yamnaya migration.  To check it we can compare Finnish genome data to eastern and western hunter-gatherers.  If the western proportion is bigger than eastern then the Finnish admixture turns out to be more western, no matter how similar it is to the Yamnaya composition.  Here is the result from Haak et al. 2015

 



















We see that the Finns have exceeding western hunter-gatherer admixture over the Yamnaya composition found from Norway, but we don't know how big the western proportion is, because we don't know exactly the Yamnaya composition.  So we can test it regarding Finns using one million SNP's now publicly available.

 
The result shows without doubt that the Finns are closer Loschour (WHG) than Karelian HG.  It shows just the same for Samara hunter-gatherers;   the Finns are much closer WHG than Samara.  And again, the same happens with western Motala_HG, both Eastern hunter-garherer groups are more distant. But a surprise comes from Hungary.  Hungarian hunter-gatherers beat also western hunter-gatherers being the closest group for Finns.

Revised Treemix-analysis using Karelian Hunter-Gatherer

In my previous Treemix test the result for Karelian hunter-gatherer (aka Karelia_HG in most studies) was tentative due to low SNP amount.  Now I have a new sample covering around 80-90% of the used data.






















After adding Finnish Tavastians they took the  pole position.



keskiviikko 25. marraskuuta 2015

Dstat using one million SNP's

I have now a great possibility to use up to one million SNP's in testing ancient genomes, thanks for new data releases.  This gives of course much more accuracy in upcoming tests.  Before going ahead I'll take a freedom to use my own genome (I have not many individual genomes with on million SNP's) and compare it to British Kent people using qpDstat.   I use Kent people because they are available from the 1000g project and there with Cornish people only original Europeans outside Mediterranean region.   If  the fifth column is positive the result shows me being closer than Kent people to the population mentioned in the third column.



maanantai 23. marraskuuta 2015

Northern hunter-gatherers portrayed by Treemix

After adding three northern hunter-gatherer groups to the data offered by Estonian BC I can now present them.  Karelia_HG is somewhat tentative based on only around 50000 snp's, converted from Haak et al.  I ran all results several times to estimate the trustworthiness.

Sweden-NHG stands for sampling Ajvide58.   You find more information about used ancient samples from here.   Most of my ancient samples are downloaded from there.





 





















Additionally a Swedish farmer from Gökhem (Gokhem2)


sunnuntai 22. marraskuuta 2015

Analyzing ancient samples is not a piece of cake, an example

Testing ancient "steppe" samples on PCA together with modern ones revealed unexpected issues.  Studies have included different sets of modern samples, some use South Asians samples, but not East Asian ones.  Probably they assume that East Asians are not relevant when testing Europeans.  Maybe it is not true, because we try to verify thousands of years history and the migration process during that time is always at least partially unknown.  Let's look three PCA-runs with different compositions.  I published the first one in my previous blog entry, to the second one I include now South Asians and to the third one also East Asians.  Due to a limitation of my Gnuplot printing routine to handle populations names I had to remove some ancient and Uralic samples from the printing stage of two global views, but PCA analysis in each phase include all samples creating proper values of x- and y-axes.   The Gnuplot routine I use tries to fit all on one page.   So I present here two PCA-plots in all three phases, each including global and close-up views.  Close-ups include all same global samples and their impact and are made only for better resolution.

In my previous analysis all "steppe" samples located very close modern Europeans.  Making  it simple let's follow Bronze Age Scandinavians (baSca).  They seem to be the westernmost group of all Bronze Age samples.





After adding South Asians all "steppe" samples move eastwards and Bronze Age Scandinavians with them to the same direction.  Regarding "steppe" samples this starts to look like Jones et al.  Sorry about flipping pictures, SmartPca does it sometimes. 






After adding East Asians changes happen again, "steppe" samples move back to west and some of Bronze Age Scandinavians are now among Basques (this is interesting indeed, think about western megaliths, but let's forget it now).







As a conclusion I would say that it is not always relevant to make up one's mind about clines between modern and ancient samples if we are not aware of the history between ancient and modern samples.   We can select modern samples coincidentally or even in a prejudiced manner and perhaps lose meaningful history.   

Some ancestral changes in Iron Age Estonia

QpAdm was designed to detect admixtures giving also probability and standard error statistics.  Two kind of parameters are inputted: admixtu...